Districts
SuburbsBlogSearch
Sign inGet started
Districts
SuburbsBlogSearch
Sign inGet started

VIC › Mansfield › Carlisle Hill Rd

3 Carlisle Hill Rd, Mansfield VIC 3722

For saleRural Property for Sale

$3,700,000–$3,800,000

For sale

Asking range

4

Bedrooms

1

Bathrooms

2

Car spaces

1,193,822.645 m²

Land

Districts ViewPrice evidencePlanningSite constraintsHistoryListing

Districts View

Given the $3,700,000–$3,800,000 ask, is this worth your time?

Why this ask?

  • FactListed for sale, asking $3,700,000–$3,800,000(Listing record · 27 Nov 2025)
  • FactLand 1,193,823 m²; no building size recorded.(Property record)
  • CalculationAsk is 393% above the Mansfield median recorded sale ($750,000, n=43, last 12 months).(Districts calculation from recorded sales)
  • CalculationIf it leased at Mansfield's advertised median rent ($540/wk), implied gross yield would be 0.76% — this is not a rent for this listing.(Districts scenario calculation)

What could make it worth more?

No upside evidence detected in the data Districts holds for this lot.

What could make it worth less?

No detected risks — but see the checklist: absence of evidence is not an all-clear.

What should you verify next?

  1. 1Official planning layers are still retrieving for this parcel — check back before relying on zoning or overlay absence.
  2. 2No hazard layer has been retrieved — confirm flood, bushfire and heritage exposure from council mapping before an offer.

Each line above is labelled. A fact is quoted from the named source, with its date. A calculation is worked out by Districts from those facts — you can check the arithmetic. An interpretation is Districts' opinion of what the evidence means, not a fact, a valuation, or advice. Anything we haven't retrieved yet is marked as missing rather than treated as a pass.

Price evidence

The ask against the evidence

Asking

$3,700,000–$3,800,000

Asking range · $3/m² of land

No recorded sale for this property.

Mansfield at a glance

6,085

People

$750,000

Median sale

$540/wk

Median rent

3.74%

Suburb gross yield

Median sale from 43 recorded sales (last 12 months) — a Districts calculation.

See the full Mansfield report →

Vs Mansfield

+393.3%

Median sale

Suburb $750,000

-2.98 pp

Gross yield

Suburb 3.74%

Suburb median $750,000 from 43 recorded sales (last 12 months) — a Districts calculation, not a portal figure.

Total cost to purchase

Based on the low end of the asking range, not a contract price.

Purchase Price
$3,700,000
Stamp Duty (Victoria)
$220,500
Transfer/Registration Fee
$3,614
Mortgage Registration (est., if financed)
$200
Legal & Conveyancing (est.)
$2,000
Building & Pest Inspection (est.)
$700
Rates & Water Adjustment at Settlement (est.)
$800
Total cash required
$3,927,814

$227,814 on top of the price (6.2% extra)

  • Stamp Duty (Victoria)
  • Transfer/Registration Fee
  • Mortgage Registration
  • Legal & Conveyancing
  • Building & Pest Inspection
  • Rates & Water Adjustment

Estimates only, at standard investor rates — no first-home or owner-occupier concessions applied. Not included: lenders mortgage insurance (usually applies when borrowing more than 80% of the price), loan application and settlement fees from your lender, the foreign-purchaser duty surcharge, and building insurance — in Queensland the property is at your risk from the first business day after signing, not from settlement. Verify with your conveyancer.

Stamp duty and transfer fees: Victoria schedules from 2026-07-01. Ongoing council rates and land tax are not included.

Rental yield

Based on the low end of the asking range, not a contract price.

Pre-filled with Mansfield's advertised median rent — not a rent for this listing.

Net yield
-0.74%
Annual cashflow (pre-tax)
$-219,820
Interest cover (DSCR)
-0.14
Annual rent
$28,080
Operating expenses
$55,500
Loan amount
$2,960,000
Annual interest
$192,400
Gross yield
0.76%

Gross yield is weekly rent × 52 ÷ price. Net yield subtracts operating expenses. Cashflow then subtracts interest-only interest on price × LVR. Tax, vacancies, and principal repayments are not included.

Open the full yield calculator →

Planning

Planning and development

Planning data is being calculated

Development activity

Data unavailable

Source

  • Provider: unavailable
  • Dataset: unavailable
  • Retrieved: not yet retrieved
  • Version: planning-v1

Planning facts are copied from official government GIS where available. Where an official property PDF exists (VicPlan, PlanBuild), Districts stores and serves that original document. Neither is a planning certificate, survey, or advice.

Site

Terrain

Terrain has not been calculated for this property yet.

Slope is calculated on a projected metric grid from a public DEM clip of the official parcel. This is not a survey, engineering, or insurance assessment.

Flood, bushfire and heritage

i

Flood

Not retrieved

Flood exposure has not been retrieved from any source for this property yet. Unknown is not the same as clear.

Bushfire

Not retrieved

Bushfire exposure has not been retrieved from any source for this property yet. Unknown is not the same as clear.

Heritage

Not retrieved

Heritage listing has not been retrieved from any source for this property yet. Unknown is not the same as clear.

Records

Property history

  1. Listed$3,700,000–$3,800,000available27 Nov 2025

Events are recorded observations from public listings, kept with their source and date. Missing values are shown as unknown, never estimated.

Capital growth

VIC

Why this lot, not just this suburb

Why could this property outperform?

Planning layers have not been retrieved for this property yet. A suburb median or growth rate is not a reason this particular lot would outperform. Funded catalyst catchments are not loaded. A TOD badge is not this product.

What could kill that thesis?

Confidence: low

Official flood overlay has not been retrieved (pending). Missing layer is unknown, not “no.” Victoria has no public statewide property-level DA API. Nearby pipeline is unknown.

Rental

Income, competition, and yield

What will it realistically rent for?

Confidence: low

No advertised rent is recorded. Suburb median rent $540/week — not this address. An inferred likely-rent range is not shown until official bond series are loaded for this dwelling type and bedrooms.

What competition will it face?

Current comparable rental listings within 400 m of this lot are not loaded. Victoria has no public statewide property-level DA API. Nearby pipeline is unknown. Supply pressure needs comparable listings near this lot plus a nearby DA pipeline. Neither is loaded. Suburb vacancy or leased-tape days are not this property’s competition.

What does the yield actually look like?

Confidence: low

Gross yield if leased at the suburb aggregate is 0.8%. The yield that matters is the one on achieved rent, which has not been inferred for this address. Net yield (land tax, rates, insurance, vacancy) is not loaded. Net yield / holding costs are not estimated outside NSW without inventing land tax.

Verdict

What this means for this property

Districts view

Not enough official evidence yet to underwrite this as an investment.

Detail

The same ten questions apply to every property. Missing flood, nearby DAs, achieved rents, or lot geometry is unknown — not “no.”

Read more

Do not treat a suburb median, an advertised yield, or a listing score as the case for this lot.

The evidence loaded so far isn't enough on its own to change a buy, offer, or walk-away decision for this property.

Evidence

What is known for this property

Districts asks the same ten questions of every property. If one shows as unknown, that data isn't published for this state or hasn't been loaded yet — the question stays visible so you can see exactly what's missing.

1 of 10 questions answered so far

  • Development optionality of this lot

    Unknown

    Planning layers have not been retrieved for this property yet.

  • Nearby development pipeline

    Unknown

    Victoria has no public statewide property-level DA API. Nearby pipeline is unknown.

  • Honest achievable rent

    Knownlow

    This is not “bond data says this address leases for $X.” The comparable figure is a suburb advertised/median rent, not this property. Official bond files (postcode or suburb × type × bedrooms) are not loaded yet.

  • Rental supply pressure

    Unknown

    Supply pressure needs comparable listings near this lot plus a nearby DA pipeline. Neither is loaded.

  • Why is this cheap?

    Unknown

    The constraint stack has not been retrieved for this lot, so Districts cannot explain a discount versus land size.

  • Lot-level flood

    Unknown

    Official flood overlay has not been retrieved (pending). Missing layer is unknown, not “no.”

  • Catalyst exposure

    Unknown

    Funded catalyst catchments are not loaded. A TOD badge is not this product.

  • This lot's DA history

    Unknown

    Development applications have not been queried for this parcel.

  • Statutory land value versus ask

    Unknown

    Statutory land value is not available as free bulk data in this jurisdiction. Do not fake it with a suburb median.

  • Net yield / holding costs

    Unknown

    Net yield / holding costs are not estimated outside NSW without inventing land tax.

Area

Mansfield in one glance

Mansfield at a glance

6,085

People

$750,000

Median sale

$540/wk

Median rent

3.74%

Suburb gross yield

Median sale from 43 recorded sales (last 12 months) — a Districts calculation.

See the full Mansfield report →

Keep researching

  • Why Mansfield? Read the area thesis →
  • What else is on the market in Mansfield →
  • Other records on Carlisle Hill Rd →

Listing material

Listed by Nutrien Harcourts Mansfield

A Rare Opportunity to Buy in Part or Whole "One Property, Two Opportunities"

Lot 1: Carlisle Hill Home Block

Approx. 122 Acres (49.70Ha)

Nutrien Harcourts Mansfield is delighted to present the Carlisle Hill Homestead Block, a premium rural lifestyle and grazing property positioned just minutes from Mansfield township.

Read the full description

Featuring a four-bedroom brick veneer residence ready for renovation, this outstanding holding presents an exceptional opportunity to add value in a highly sought-after location. Set amid established gardens and productive grazing land, the property enjoys stunning High Country views and the convenience of being just four minutes from Mansfield's High Street

Well suited to cattle, sheep or equine pursuits, the gently undulating country features fertile soils, mature red gums and reliable water infrastructure. Multiple dams and a bore provide dependable year-round water for a variety of farming operation

Whether you're seeking a productive farm, a country lifestyle property, or a family retreat close to all the amenities of Mansfield, this exceptional holding presents a rare opportunity in one of Victoria's most tightly held rural districts.

Key Features

• Approx. 122 acres (49.7 hectares)

• Four-bedroom brick veneer residence (circa 1960s)

• Established home gardens and house yard

• Productive grazing country

• Mature red gums throughout

• Excellent water infrastructure including dams and bore

• Multiple paddocks

• Suitable for cattle, sheep and horses

• Panoramic rural views

Just 4 minutes from Mansfield township. Easy access to Mt Buller, Lake Eildon and the Victorian High Country. A rare opportunity to secure a productive rural lifestyle property in an outstanding Mansfield location.

Lot 2: Carlisle Hill Grazing Block

Approx. 173 Acres (70.02 Ha)

Nutrien Harcourts Mansfield proudly offers the Carlisle Hill Grazing Block. Comprising 173 acres (approx.) across two separate titles, including a 139-acre title and a 34-acre title, a highly productive parcel of High Country farming land ideally located only minutes from Mansfield.

Featuring fertile soils, gently undulating topography and attractive district views, this versatile holding presents an excellent opportunity for livestock producers, investors and lifestyle buyers seeking quality grazing country in a blue-chip rural location.

Currently utilised for cattle production, the property offers strong agricultural credentials with excellent pasture potential. Mature red gums provide natural character, shade and shelter, creating an appealing balance of productivity and environmental appeal.

With Mansfield's services, schools, restaurants and retail facilities only minutes away, and Victoria's premier alpine and recreation destinations on your doorstep, this property represents both a practical farming asset and a secure long-term investment.

Key Features

• Approx. 173 acres, Two titles (139acres, 34acres)

• Productive grazing land

• Fertile soils

• Undulating terrain with attractive outlooks

• Mature red gums

• Ideal for cattle, sheep or equine enterprises

• Excellent investment or expansion opportunity

• Only 4 minutes to Mansfield township

• Close to Mt Buller, Lake Eildon and the Victorian High Country

Quality grazing country in an outstanding location, offering productivity, lifestyle appeal and long-term value.

Listing description written by Matt Pollard, Nutrien Harcourts Mansfield — reproduced as published, not verified by Districts.

Districts

Australian property research from recorded sales, listings, and official layers. Missing data is shown as unavailable, never filled in.

Research

  • Property search
  • Suburb profiles
  • Blog
  • Calculators
  • Follow suburbs
  • Sign in

Learn

  • How we use data
  • What's covered
  • Questions
  • Who it's for
  • Access

Company

  • About
  • Contact
  • support@districts.com.au

Legal

  • Privacy
  • Terms

© 2026 Districts

districts.com.au

Research purposes only. Not personal financial advice, a valuation, or a planning certificate. Always speak to a licensed financial adviser before you act.